Christians ‘Face Routine Torture’ in Afghanistan


Staff member
Christians ‘Face Routine Torture’ in Afghanistan
By Raymond Ibrahim

Originally Published by the Gatestone Institute.

The estimated 15,000-20,000 Christians who remain in Afghanistan after the Taliban takeover “face routine torture and persecution from both the government and their own friends, families and communities,” according to a new report.

This is not a new development. From the start on August 15, 2021, matters significantly worsened for Christians when the Biden administration abruptly surrendered Afghanistan to the Taliban. The poorly-planned defeat of U.S. troops caused the Central Asian nation to fall right back into the grips of the Taliban, one of the Islamic terrorist groups complicit in the 9/11 attacks on the U.S.

During the chaos of withdrawal, there were reports that the Biden administration was actively preventing the rescue of Christian minorities from what has since become the sharia-enforcing Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.

Once U.S. surrender was complete, reports stated that “Taliban militants are even pulling people off public transport and killing them on the spot if they’re Christians.” Any Afghan caught with a Bible app on their phone was reportedly executed. “How we survive daily only God knows,” a Christian Afghan reported on condition of anonymity. “But we are tired of all the death around us.”

According to the World Watch List 2022, which ranks the 50 nations where Christians are most persecuted for their faith, Afghanistan is now the worst nation in the world in which to be Christian.

Voice of the Martyrs, an international humanitarian nonprofit, also offers the following about the 99.8% Muslim nation:

“Beatings, torture and kidnappings are routine for Christians in Afghanistan…Christians are martyred every year in Afghanistan, but their deaths generally occur without public knowledge. A few are also in prison…Christian converts from Islam are often killed by family members or other radicalized Muslims before any legal proceedings can begin.”

Revealingly, immediate family members are most prone to persecute and murder converts to Christianity. As Todd Nettleton of Voice of the Martyrs recently noted, although conditions for Christians have “certainly worsened” since the Taliban takeover, “the first line of persecution is your family members, it’s your neighbors.” He detailed how converts arouse suspicion when, for instance, they fail to appear for prayers at their mosques. In just the first eight months of the Taliban’s resumption of power, one clandestine Christian man had to relocate his family three times due to the threat of discovery.

While Afghanistan was never welcoming for Christians, matters became significantly worse in after the U.S. invasion of 2001. Because Muslims tend to conflate Christians with the West in general, and America in particular — based on the popular but erroneous belief among Muslims that the West and America are still Christian — Afghan Christians were especially targeted after the U.S. invasion as a form of “collective punishment.”

In neighboring Pakistan, as usual (here, here and here) , Christian minorities were also attacked:

“Life on any given day for Pakistani Christians is difficult. But members of Pakistan’s Christian community say now they’re being persecuted for U.S. drone attacks on Islamic militants hiding on the border with Afghanistan. The minority, which accounts for an estimated one percent of the country’s 170 million [mostly Muslim] population, says because its faith is strongly associated with America, it is targeted by Muslims.”

“When America does a drone strike, they come and blame us,” said one Christian. “They think we belong to America. It’s a simple mentality.”

Western leadership, for its part, is extremely careful not to show any concern for Christian minorities—a sentiment that goes hand in hand with Western acquiescence to Islamic sensibilities. If anything, Western leaders are more prone to turn a blind eye to, if not actively discriminate against, already persecuted Christians—as was the case with the UN and the UK, and the US during the Obama administration.

There is a final aspect to the plight of Christians in Afghanistan, one that more “pragmatic” observers will, no doubt, cite to blame the persecuted themselves. Apparently, many of the thousands of Christians that remain in Afghanistan are there for the same reason that motivated the earliest Christians. According to David Curry, of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom:

“Many Christians did flee Afghanistan when the Taliban took over. Some did stay because they want to be ‘salt and light’ [Matt. 5:13-16 Matt] in a theological sense in that country, even though it became more hostile. So, they want to be part of the community. They love their country. It’s totally understandable why many fled, but there is an embattled Christian community there in Afghanistan still today.”

Todd Nettleton confirms that view:

“[Those remaining Christians] made the incredible bold decision to stay in the country. And their attitude was, ‘Listen, if all the Christians flee the country, who’s going to be here to share the gospel, who’s going to be here to be the church?’ And so they made that courageous decision to stay, even knowing that the Taliban would be taking over; knowing it was a very risky thing.”

However one wishes to interpret this, here are the weak and vulnerable, altruistically risking their lives for what they at least believe is the good of their fellow man, while many of the world’s rich and powerful, who habitually preach about “human rights” and “religious freedom” — at least when it suits their agendas, for example, by creating racial divisions in the U.S., demonizing Israel, or covering up for Islamist radicalization — have seemingly done everything possible to worsen their situation.

Raymond Ibrahim, author of the new book, Defenders of the West: The Christian Heroes Who Stood Against Islam, is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Gatestone Institute, a Shillman Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center, and a Judith Rosen Friedman Fellow at the Middle East Forum.

Belle of Grace

Longing for Home
Are these trusted organizations? I'm always skeptical of donating to organizations and not knowing whether the money will actually help the people it needs to.
I'm the same way when it comes to donating to strangers. We generally give our contributions to individual missionaries that we 'know' are doing the work. Whenever someone is thinking about donating to an organization that is unfamiliar to them, it's a good idea to check the website of the organization or call their office and see how donations are distributed. I like giving to groups that use 100% (or almost) for the cause stated in their brochures. What % goes toward advertising, mailings, administrative costs, etc. Case in point: Over 10 yrs ago we attended a prophecy conference in a large city. There were several ministries who set up their tables with little freebies and pamphlets describing their work. I don't recall if we gave a one-time donation to a particular organization that 'still' sends us monthly updates from their group. Postage is cheaper for bulk mailing, but I think these groups should carefully assess whether or not the outlays in postage for 10 yrs that result in no donations is good financial stewardship.